CBS News legal analyst Andrew Cohen took some major jabs at the PR profession in a report yesterday. Watching from my kitchen, and listening to the attacks on “PR ethics,” my first thought was: Hey, maybe my professional association will mobilize itself and make some lemonade. Second, I realized that sometimes it is just too easy to pick on publicists. (By the way, the joke that “PR ethics” is an oxymoron is as old as plastic silverware.)
At issue is the tell-all book by former White House spokesman Scott McClellan. I haven’t read it, and the content doesn’t really matter for my argument.
You see, CBS is blasting away at a guy who had what is arguably the most high profile PR job in the world. McClellan addressed talented network news pros daily and was a regular on virtually every newscast in the country for a couple years. Guess what: He is not a spokesman for my industry. Attacking the PR profession through McClellan is like attacking major league baseball through Barry Bonds. He is one guy at the top level, and his job is nothing like that of 99 percent of the PR people that I have known in my 18 years in the business.
Most of us fall into the “toil in obscurity” category of business. We don’t preside over news conferences, clash with network anchors or joust with grizzled investigative reporters. Many of us create internal communications programs, distribute run-of-the-mill news releases, ghost-write articles for little-known but influential trade magazines and jockey for such life/death events as the circus and the boat show. Certainly many of us have a hand in shaping news on occasion, and if we’re good, we have helped avert a crisis or two; but most of us never have a reason to lie, obfuscate or spin to any major degree. For CBS to say all of PR is bad because of McClellan is like saying all baseball players (major, minor and pickup leagues included) are steroid abusers because of Bonds. It’s laughable.
--John